A LETTER FROM A Member of the Oppofition T O | LoropD_ B------. Le ea a a Quoth Hudibras, you lie fo ope That J, without a Telefcope— Fafily can vie, Where you tell Truth, and where you lie. Hup. ee LONDON: Printed for G. Burnet, at Bifhop Burnet’s-Head, in the Strand. Mopccuxii. Da 5 a casa aerate io ea to cemew we Rinteiennsbwctinar ‘ant L ET ‘PE RR, ee, My LORD, Y OU may, perhaps, be furprifed at this public addrefs, after fo long 2 filence. But as] find the advocates of your party have lately raifed their voices high againft us, I think it is time to anfwer their charge, in the fame manner they have attacked us; and as they have lifted under your banner, I know no where fo proper to apply as to the head-quarters. Were I to enter into all the minutia of your adm n, and the meafures you have purfued, which has given rife to the pre- fent oppofition, I fhould {well this letter into a volume; and mutt therefore leave them to your future biographer, who, in giving your chara@ter at length, will neceffarily blazon our glory ; to dwell upon fuch facts as have B been bd becu fo ftrikingly obvious, and fo manifeltly prejudicial to the nation, that every eye has been witnefs to their effects, and every ton- gue has re-ecchoed the difapprobation of. We are charged with per/onal dilguft and national antipathy, as the principal foundations whereon we have ratfed the fabric of our oppo- tion——that it is not particular meafures, but particular men, that we diflike—and that we have a good employment more at beart than a good peace. Had we not concurred with you in all your meafures in the beginning of your adm n, without te‘lifying the leaft difap- probation, either to your perfon, or your coun- try—had we not applauded every expedient that was devifed, and partook of their fuccefs— and had not mof ofus refigned our employ- ments at a time, when no others were va- cant that we could reafonably expect would fall to our fhare; fuch accufations might bear at leaft the femblance of probability : But thefe are facts fo notorioufly known, that they only require being mentioned, to be in- conteftably proved, and evince the falfity of our enemies infinuations. The object of Mr. P—’s refignation was fo manifeft to all the world, that itis amazing any writers, however fervily difpofed to vili- fy, could ever attribute it to any other caule, than the difapprobation of the meafure he fo earneftly er= Fees «co ee a eal Pe eee earneftly recommended, and which he fo evidently proved, to be the only expedient. for giving a greater luftre to our arms, and more permanent fecurity to our conftitution, in church and ftate—I mean a dec’aration of war againft Spain in Oétober 1761. This was rejected—he forefaw all the dif- honour and misfortunes that would necef- farily accrue from this inattention. Notwith- ftanding the propofal was approved the en- fuing month, notwithftanding his —— re- warded him with a handfome penfion for his pat fervices, and a title for thofe of his wife —He forefaw the lofs of Newfoundland, and the prefent (What jhall I call it?) peace; and would therefore no longer have the guidance of that adm——n, whofe luftre might have been tarnithed by fuch inglorious events. When I fay Mr. P— forcfaw the lofs of Newfoundland, Ido not mean that be wifked it, to give a colour to planning an oppofition, which till then there was littie or no pretext for (fave the non-declartaion of war againft Spain in October inftead of November). Far be that from me, or any of us, who form the prefent antiminifterial party; I only mean, that there being no other fortifications raifed during the whole war, and to the end of his refplendent adm-——n, or any more men of wat kept upon that ftation, during that pe- B 2 riod 4 riod, than at the time of its being /urrendere ed tothe Frerich, he had reafon to be appre-+ henfive of its difmemberment from the firft commencementof hoftilities—and he had alfa reafon to think himfelf very lucky the event did not happen whilft he was at the head of affairs; not that it could have been impu- ted as any crime to fo popylar a m r, for the nation to have fuftained one lofs (even though we had never regained it) after fuch fignalifed and repeated fuccefles: but his glory might hereby have been diminifhed, and the people might have perceived, or imagined they perceived, infallibility was not the lot of any man, and the Patriot could not always conquer. It istrue, the retaking of this ifland, in fome meafure, wiped off the flur of negli- gence and inattention which you, my Lord, fo greatly merited, in not having more /ea/on- ably provided for the defence of that valuable pofieffion, ata time you ought to have been ac- quainted with the defigns of the French there- upon, though four frigates only. might have taken it. And it is to this infight of all the operations of the French navy, which we were fo minutely acquainted with during Mr. P—’s adminiftration, that we may at- tribute his intentional remif[nefs, (or, in other words, national aconomy) in not fortifying and fecyring that ifland ; being certain that na ( 5 ) no hips could be deftined againft it, though they might accidentally efcape out of Brett, whilft our fieet in the Bay fo compleatly blocked up the French navy. But when any the leaft merit is imputed to the retaking of Newfoundland, it fhould be remembered, that no perfon in England could participate of it, as there was no plan jaid here for fuch an attempt. The Ame- ricans atchieved it, and therefore engrofs all the honour. Upon the fame principles, the then m y were, in every fenfible man’s eye, exculpated from the fhame attending the furrender of Minorca and Braddock’s de- feat. Blakeney never received any orders to eapitulate, nor in all likelihcod would, if he had held out fix months longer ; nor did the American commander follow his inftructions from home. So that there is fcarce any prince or minifter in Europe, except the King of Pruffia, that is anfwerable for their gene- rals conduét, as circumftances muft necefla- rily vary the execution of the plan of ope- rations, however well laid; and {cope muft be left for the judgment of a commander upon the fpot. The King of Pruffia being moft frequently with the active part of his army, is an exception to this; and to the want of this allowance to the Imperial gene- rals, whofe inftructions muft be tenacioufly followed, we may impute many of their de- feats ; | | ; . ‘ ; ] : if | (6) feats; as they are obliged to fend to Vienna ) i for frefh orders upon every the leaft alteration | 4 of affairs, and to wait for the return of the } q courier, though they may in the mean time | | | have the fineft opportunity of charging the enemy to advantage. This they have as frequently loft, and with it a battle, inftead ) I of gaining a victory. | f If it fhould be afked, as the m——y de- | i rive no merit, then, from the recovery of this i ifland, how were they blameable for its lofs? il The anfwer is ready, becaufe they! fhould | have fecured it from any attempts of the ene- my; or, if they left it in the fame defence- lefs ftate they found it, without its being at- tacked for fix ycars; becaufe they did not procure intelligence of the deftination of every frigate that failed from France, or any of the iflands belonging to that crown, and q becaufe zndividuals fuffered by its being a a fhort time in the hands of the French, and individuals have a right to complain; and no . man has ever yet thought himfelf unautho- R rifed to abufe a m———, or condemn a mea- is fure, that did not chime in with his particu- Jar intereft. Though the m-———y derived no per/fonal | merit from the retaking of Newfoundland, =, and fuffered greatly in their reputation by its | lofs; yet the flur thrown vpon them was) © in fome meafure wiped off by this anit | —wit es = «with what reafon ‘I will not pretend to determine. No fooner was that ifland in the hands of the enemy, and the report of a peace being upon the carpet, but the policy of the m——r was feen through, in yielding up Newfoundland to the French, that they might reftore it to us as an apparent equiva- lent for Cape Breton, or perhaps Canada. This your Lordthip was publickly accufed of. You alone know the fincerity of your inten- tions; and if you have derived no merit from our being fo early repofleffed of it, you have at leaft thereby cait off this imputation. But as we are to look upon the recovery as an accidental ftroke, planned without your know- ledge, and atchieved without your defire ; fo the impartial world cannot perceive any other honour you derive from it, but that of hav- ing it put out of your power to play this po- litical humbug with the court of Verfailles. Thus, my Lord, you fee, that, on whatever fide we view the lofs of Newfoundland, all the blame, all the negligence, all the difhonour, will reft upon your Lordfhip, without any part of it falling upon Mr. P—, or any of his coadjutors. This, then, was certainly one of the prin- cipal caufes of our refigning our employ- ments; for though we were convinced of your Tory principles, and your being a Scotchman, we had neverthelefs till now united ( 8 ) unitéd with you, acted in concert in thé fanié adm——~n, and believed you an honeft man. As you never pretended to fupport indefeafible hereditary wight, gave the leaft glance of bringing in the pretender, but. feemed the moft ftrenuous:of any. courtier for the Pro- teftant caufe, and the houfe of Hanover, we had no room to/think you a Jacobite. You entertained no high notions of arbitrary power; but juftly confidered our conftitution com- pofed of the three ‘tates, King, Lords, and Commons,. without whofe coneurrent aid ‘no law could be framed, no fupplies could be granted. The liberties of the people you feemed to have a juft and valuable fenfe. of, and at the fame time confidered it neceflary to fupport the legal prerogative of the crown. Thefe, which we. found the prevalent prin- ciples of the modern Tories, we could difco- ver no impropriety in ; :and, though we pro- fefied ourlelves Whigs, we thought a coali- tion of parties under thefe circumstances was no way incompatible. If it thould be aiked, as we made part of the Tory adm——n for atime, were we not become Tories? No; we had blended the parties in fo nice and cu- rjous a manner, that it was difficult to difco- ver where the Whig ended, or where the Tory began. But we were neverthelefs Whigs-— {taunch Whigs—which we now approve our- {ulves, in oppofing every ftep of the Tory adm——n | | i I ] ak Be. adm——n which is not thus properly iea- vened. Should this carry the face of any feem- ing contradiction, let it be remembered, that parties are only names ; that a man’s actions conftitute him a good or a bad man—As long as the firft charaéterife him, he is to be efteemed and affociated with, let his politi- cal principles go by whatever-title they may ; but if the latter fhould diftinguifh him, it is not his being called a Whig that will recom- mend him to the honeft part of mankind. Bolingbroke was by turns both Whig and Tory, and he was equally defpifed by both— Moie recent examples might be produced. But to the point. I fay, my Lord, as your political principles fo nearly chimed in with our’s, we thought it no blot in our efcutcheon, to make part of a Tory adm——n, though we profeffed our- felves Whigs, as long as the meafures you purfued were fuited to thofe profeffions, and tended tothe good of your country; but when we found you even negligent in cne part of the world to the defence of our va- luable pofleffions, and even attentive in ano- ther to terras of pacification, which we could not expect (in the beginning of a Spanith war) could yet be very honourable for us— we thought it was time to take ourfelves ont of the ‘fory adm——n, and profefs our- felves Whigs. C Venal ( 10 ) _Venal and corrupt adminifrations, are fo much the phrafeology of difappointed am- bition, that though I could prove that of your Lordthip’s both the one and the other, I thould be loth to attempt the tafk, left it fhould be fufpected I gave up my thare in it, becaufe my authcrity was limited, or my rapacity circumfcribed; as it might be threwdly fufpected that m y extent of power being called in queftion, or the war being nea. ly at an end, whereby the pecuniary pro- fits of my office would be greatly leflened, I was difgufted with the infraction, or thought myfelf qualified for other departments of more future value and importance. No, my Lord, far from this; I will give you all your due ; avarice is the leaft of your vices: to evince this, we need recur only to that part of your adm n, when you filled the poft of S y of St—e, and fo bene- ficently diminifhed your own revenue to in- creafe that of your clerks to double their falary. Your ample fortune certainly {ets you above any mean artifices to amuafs riches ; and if you cannot /rve upon anegg a day, as a great orator declared in an honourable houfe, be could, in order to prove his pa- triotifin, and the finall influence pecuniary advantages could have upon him ; you cer- tainly may have as much reafon to defpife money, and have the good of your country at e fo eft it in it, ower being ‘Pro- pught No, all CES ¢ that filled yene- 0 in- their r fets hes ; y, as rable ; pa- niary cer- {pife intry at Pass = fie os Visi v A - ECE RS LIER MEG IIE FO RTS I ( ir) at heart, as your own private {take is to the full as great as his. You fee, my Lord, I make you all the allowances that can reafonably be expected from an adve-fary. I exculpate you from avarice, and want of generofity; nor do I directly tax you with venality and corruption ; but that part of your political principles {fo immediately connected with the great rule of your adm——n, now become fo glaring, 1s what can never be reconciled with found Whiggifm, is what can never be approved by true Englifhmen, and the real /overs of their country. What I mean, my Lord, is, that unbounded prerogative you allow your Sov—n, to appoint his own officers, and continue them in poft as long as fuits his pleafure : this the Whigs have itrenuoufly and effec- tually oppofed ever fince the houfe of Hano- ver came to the throne, down to the prefent time. It is impoflible for a Prince to ac- quaint himfelf with the paffions, difpofitions, and abilities of individuals, who always ap- pear in mafk before the throne, fo as to chufe thofe who are the propereft qualified for filling pofts of confequence; and with regard to inferior employs, it is ftill more impracticable : fo that it is properly the pro- vince of a fagacious m——r, or his coadju- tors, to felect fuitable objects, make their ap- C 2 pointments, : | | ( mm ) pointments, and regulate their pofts. No man was ever better qualified for this pro- vince than Sir Robert W——e, who never ‘et his mafter have the leaft trouble upon his hands in thefe refpeéts : but having people of integrity and capacity always ready, he filled up every place as it became vacant with the utmoft eafe, difpatch, and propriety. Hence that good order and harmony which fubfifted during the greateft part of his adm n; hence that expedition in bufinefs of a public and private nature ; hence that national ec - nomy upon every occafion —- that good un- der ftanding at home and abroad, but particu- Jarly the latter fo clearly manifefted upon the moft important occafions—eleCticns ! and hence that unufual acquiefcence to every mea- {ure propofed by the m——r, and fecured by a maj—ty ! Thefe were fome of the many advantages derived to the nation from the limitation of prerogative by the Whigs. His fuccefior Mr. P—, who followed the footfteps of Sir Robert in every thing that tended to the pu- blic good, was equally affiduous in taking off all trouble and care from his mafter in thefe appointments and nominations; and had not his death (which every honeft Whig may lament) that has fince cccafioned fo many changes and innovations, unluckily happened, we might {till have feen things | | conducted 353 ee tee tether Soles = 3 Sse eee ee Oe. a a. ee aa | See 2 Noe pro- never n his le of filled the ence ifted —N ; ubli¢ eC - un- ticu- ) the and mea- ured ages n of efior Sir pu- cing - in and hig | fo kily ngs ited N , 4 Ay 4 a ( 13°) conducted in this happy courfe, It muft, however, be acknowledged, that, even in his days, there were envious courtiers, who would fometimes tingle in the ears of their mafter, that he fubmitted himfelf entirely to the government of hism——r ; and that his late M———y once went fo far as to pro- mife the Duke of R- a fmall poft for a perfon he had recommended ; the vacancy was however filled up by Mr, P— in favour of his adb/e friend. ‘The Duke took an op- portunity of reminding his M——y of his promife, who frankly acknowledged, That King G— had promifed it to bis Grace, but that King P—wm had given it to another. From this time his M—y never attempted to nominate for any employment, and P—m, with his confederates, were fecure of every poft of honour or profit, from Lord Ch—r down to the loweft branch of the Excife- Office. This defpotifm, it is true, they car- ried with fomewhat too high a band; and it were to be wifhed, for the honour of the Whigs, that the geueral refignatton in one day, when the late rebellion was at its crifis, did not find a place in the annals of our times. Had they not before fo manifeftly proved their atte-hment to the h—e of H——, their enemies might have given fome groundlefs infinuations not highly favourable of their zeal ( 14 ) zeal to the Proteftant caufe, and the prefent happy eftablifhment. All the happy effects of this limitation of prerogative are at an end—Your mafter ap- points his own fervants, and you have lately inftilled fuch notions of power in him, that he thinks he has a right to keep you at his elbow, in defpite of all the reprefentations that have been made againft you, in defpite of all the hideous characters that have been drawn of you, in writing and prints, in def- pite of all infinuations to your difadvantage, with regard to your intimacy with the—-—, —in defpite of the Whigs—in defpite of the oppofition. This, my Lord, is one of thofe alarming circumftances, that has raifed fo many ene- mies to your adm——n : had there not been a new bridge erected over the Tweed, or had not you yourfelf been born in Scotland, I very much queftion whether you could have efcaped cenfure from the Whigs, as foon as the fundamental principles which lay for foe time dormant, was fo compleatly ma- nifefted. At fo critical a period, was it not the high- eft pitch of imprudence in your Lordfhip to fet on foot a negotiation between us and France, for bringing about a peace ? Was it not flying i in the face of the oppofition, to publith the preliminaries at the beginning a the niki Nap SG 8s GEER SS refent SSS Sse a» gle on of ap- lately , that at his a ations e{pite ben 1 def- tage, aso Panpeeescy »f the — Sa ming ‘ ene- @ been | r had d, I have On as ’ for ' ma- ligh- Ip to and Tas it n, to ig of the iS pM REE SES AGT oo ee i ay Be Bs ik ( 15 ) the feffion, before the fupplies for the enfi- ing year were granted? Could you expect them to be filently read, without being c.n- vafied or criticifed? Had we not the negotia- tion of the preceding year before us, with which we might comr ire, and at all events draw conclufions in favour of the terms of- fered in 1761, though then rejected? Had we not the ultimatum and the uti piffidetis to recur to, whereby we might prove that a peace would have been ,more eligible laft year than now? However far advan- ced the negotiation might have been, it was the higheft pitch of rafhnefs to divulge the fecret till the clofe of the feffion, when all the bufinefs was over: the members had then retired to their fylvan paftimes, and would have forgot the terms of pacification by that time they met again. The curiofity of the people would have fubfided ; the worft peace that could have been made, would have been but a nine days wonder; the fup- plies for the current year would have been abundantly granted, and every thing would. have been conducted without debate or ani- mofity. But, as you have rifqued the publication of the fums at this period, every body, in and out of doors, will canvas them; every body will condemn them. Though the pri- mary object of the war, that is, afcertaining the ( 16 ) the limits‘of our North American Colonies; and fecuring them from future incurfions, is more than compaffed, by our retaining all Canada, and that part of Louifiana, extend- ing from the Apalachean mountains to the river Miffifippi: though we have alfo ac- quired and retained Cape Breton, the Dun- kirk of America, and key to the Gulph: of St. Laurence ; though we have divided the neutral iflands in our ‘avour, and gained Granada and the Grenadillas therewith ; —~ added Florida, as a barrier to our continen- tial poffeffions in America, have gained the liberty of cutting logwood without interrup- tion at Honduras and Campeachy, and pof- fefs that valuable acquifition of the ifland of Senegal, and therewith the trade of the whole river of the fame name in Africa: no body can difpute that we have made con- ceffion, greatly inglorious, highly difhonour- able: it is in vain to urge with your partifans, it is the beft peace England ever made, and cali upon the negotiation of the treaty of Aix- la-Chapelle, to compare the terms of the definitive treaty of 1748 with thofe of 1762. Our affairs were then very differently fituated ' from what: they are at prefent; and though we had then made ourfelves mafters of Cape’ Breton, it was our only conqueft: it is true: we gave it up, and fent hoftages to bind the bargain; but what was the reftitution of a: fingle . pit Pi ete Foose, Rees eee reyes : Cnt aes a ae ms 5 2 Rasa SS ey ( 17 ) fingle place, compared to that of the valuable iflands of Martinico and Guadalupe * As to the noble Lords who went as fureties for the execution of that article, they were treated with the greateft refpect at Verfailles, and not thrown into the Baftile, as the fcandalous prints of thofe times fuggefted. The advocates for the preliminaries lay great ftrefs upon our being repaid the charge we have been at in fupporting the French pri- foners during the war, as an object that was not in the leaft attended to in the former negotiation; and they take for granted, the court of Verfailles gives up all claim to the captures made before the declaration of war, becaufe nu mention is made of them in the preliminary articles, though Mr. Bufly fo ftrongly infifted upon this pointin 1761. We have been repeatedly aflured from various. hands, that the preliminaries made public do not contain all the terms that were figned at Fontainbleau the 3d of November, and fince ratified ; but that there are feveral other articles kept fecret, fome of which have, however, tranfpired in the political world, and amongft thefe is the provifion of indemnification we are to make the French for the. above-mentioned captures, Some infinuate, that the other fecret articles regard the difpofitions that are to take place in fa- vour of the King of Pruffia and the Soeen D Oo ( 18 ) of Hungary in Germany; but the more fanguine anti-pacific-inveftigators infift upon it, that they relate to other reftitutions, or ceffions that we are to make to France and Spain, and which you, my Lord, did not dare publickly avow. If this is the cafe, you have made a fine piece of work of it indeed ; and as fooner or later the nature and tendency of thofe fecret articles will come out, what do you imagine will then be the confequence?— There is but one argument that leads me to think thefe fuggeftions may be premature, and that is, if your Lordthip had intended to have dealt thus underhandedly with the peo- ple, it certainly would have occurred to you, that there was no reafon for publifhing the re- ftitution of Martinico and Guadalupe, or in- deed any part of the preliminaries; at Jeaft till the clofe of the feffions, when the fup- plies being granted, as in full time of war, if this indemnification for the French cap- tures made before the declaration of war had been to take place, you might eafily have drawn it out of the furplus of the grants for 1763, without the leaft noife being made about it. To fupport the argument, then, we will fuppofe that no other reftitutions or ceffions are to take place, but thofe mentioned in the public preliminaries ; are they not fufhcient to Ss ww & = = = 2 Oh oD rome 62 © ba we [ nd = ity ; 5S = - fp eR sg arid eit ig toa gre eae a Hale reas Sea ( 19 ) to ftigmatife this nation for ever as thick- {culled negotiators? Do they not corroborate what we have been fo often rallied upon, that, let us gain ever fo many victories over the French in the field, they always conquer us in the cabinet? Not bot I think we re- tain land and iflands enough in America; far I fee no likelihood of our fettling all Canada, and that tract of land between our back fet- lements and the Miffiffipi, or indeed of what fervice it would be, without we had a mind ‘to make our colonies rival the mother-coun- try in power and riches, which many pa- triots and politicians have long been appre- henfive of, before we were in poffeffion of fuch a great extent of territory. Were land the only object of war and conqueft, we need not go fo far as America; we have fome hun- dred miles of good foil in Scotland, Wales, and Ireland, which remain uncultivated, for no other reafon, that I could ever find, except it were the want of hands, or a proper fpirit of induftry being excited amongit the people. Either of thefe caufes will occafion our new acquifitions in North America remaining a defert. And as to iflands in America, if we had been in want of them, I apprehend the Bahamas, fo numerous, and, I doubt not, fruitful, if properly cultivated, would not have remained fo long in our poficffion, with- D 2 out St a ay seme ba de EE 1 Slee a. 20 out being fettled, or made any ufe of, by the Englith. Hence, my Lord, it will appear the refti- tutions we have made do not fo much affect our intere(t as our honour. It would have been glorious for us to have made a peace upon the bafis of an uti pofidetis. It would have deterred the French from ever infulting us again, and kept all the powers of Europe in awe, left they fhould have incurred our difpleafure, and fuftained fuch loffes as they would have had no hopes of regaining. The writers who attempt to fupport the meafures you have purfued, pretend the greateft regard has been paid, in framing the preliminaries in queftion, to the trade and commerce of Great Britain; that new branches are hereby ftruck out in every quarter of the globe, and new channels opened to the re- moteft, and as yet unknown parts of Ame- rica. This they attempt to exemplify in our acquifition of Canada, which they affure -fe- cures us all the fur and beaver trade of that quarter of the world, and enables us to fabri- cate various branches of manufaCtures where-~ in they enter, at a much cheaper rate than we could before, whereby we fhall not only rival all the other commercial powers of Ea- rope in the peltry trade of North America alone, but alfo in all thofe other manufactures whereof they make a part, by being enabled to .__ ££ Ae S| 6 See ll —<— — —_ a een — 21 to under(ell them at foreign markets. They then endeavour to point out the immediate advantages refulting from our being in pof- feffion of the ifland of Senegal, which gives us the command of the trade of the whole river of that name, and the country adjacent, and. pretend we fhall fave near half a million yearly in the fingle article of gum, whic we ufed to pay to foreigners, befides the negroe, tooth and gold-duft trades, which are carried on from thence. They then firetch away to the continent of South Ame- rica, and talk loudly of the benefits which will accrue to.us from the unlimited per- miflion we have obtained of cutting log- wood at Campeachy and Honduras ; a pri- vilege. we could never before obtain in all our treaties with the court of Madrid. Nay, they would go as far as Afia, and have the confidence to tell us the advantages we. have gained there, and ftill retain, will enable us to rival all the Eaft India companies of Eu- rope, as we have fo compleatly fecured the Nabohs intereft. and good opinion ; fhave deflroyed the trade of the French there fome years, notwithftanding the reflitutions made them, and asthe Dutch are there upon the decline. In anf{wer to this, it will be only necefiary to obferve, that our prefent trade to (Canada is fo far from being of that im- portance it is reprefented, that thofe who "have ( 22 ) have dealt in the peltry of that country, fince we have been pofleffed of it, have been lofers, by reafon of the full refolution taken by the Hudfon-bay company, to underfell indivi- duals in every article they deal in ; fo that till fome regulation is made upon this head, this trade is not likely to produce the pro- mifed happy effects. As to our trade to Senegal, it certainly is a very advantageous and lucrative one, and will neccffaril,, lower the price of printed cotton and linens, as fo great a quantity of the gum coming from thence is ufed in thofe manufactures, and as this can now be bought at fo {mall a proportionate price to what we ufed formerly to pay foreigners. But asa monopoly of this trade has been promifed to a certain confiderable dealer, we cannot rea- fonably expect he will have the good of his country fo much at heart, as to preponderate againft his private intereft, and prevail upon him to fell this commodity at its prefent low rice, The privilege of cutting and fhipping log- wood at Honduras and Campeachy, without angoyance or interruption, is certainly an ob- ject of fome confequence to the Weft Indian traders ; but as the point fo much ‘conten- ded fer under Sir Robert’s adm n, (which to be fure he could not obtain, any more than the privilege now granted) of no fearch, is not Pe ee ge ( 23 ) not acquiefced to, we imagine this trade will not be productive of thofe great emoluments which were at firft expected from it, as it is well known, it is the interloping trade of ne- groes to the Spanifh main, which are paid for in hard dollars, that makes this trade fo lucra- tive and defirous. As the Spaniards are per- feétly acquainted with this circumftance atten- ding the logwood trade, it is not to be expec- ted they will ever give us a public grant of a thing fo detrimental to them.—But the objec ftill remains. I muft acknowledge, I believe our Eaft India company is at this time the moft opu- lent. and beft eftablifhed of any in Afia, and that the reduction of Pondicherry, and the other French fettlements there, muft greatly interrupt their trade for fome confiderable time: but as it has long fince been a moot point, whether our Eaft India trade, as it is now catried on, though of infinite profit to individuals, is of any real fervice to the na- tion ; fo, till this is decided, it will be impoi- fible for me to perceive the advantages.we can reap, as a people, from our fuccefies, and the prefent thriving ftate of our affairs in Afia. Thus, my Lord, you fee the pretended emoluments we are to expect from the ac- quifitions and reftitutions we make by the peace, however pompous an appearance they may ( 24 ) may parade upon paper by the writers of your party, lofe the very femblance of ad- vantages, when put to a cloie and impartial examen. It is evident, from what I have faid, that we have more lands in our poffeffion than we thall people and cultivate, unlefs, with our ufual friendfhip and politenefs, we provide for the Germans better than their own ptincesand mafters will, and make,an emigra- tion of fome thoufand more Palatines to America, in furnifhing them with all the ne- ceffaries both for their voyage, aad future fettlement. This would be but common gratitude in us, as we have conquered America in Germany, to enable the conquerors to re- tain their acquifitions; and who fo proper as a colony of Brandenburghers, who have fo eminently diftinguifhed themfelves as faldiers . and Proteftants this war? This would bea meafure highly eligible, if there were not tea~ fon to fear fome future ambitious king of Proffia might difcover a prior right than us; or the French, or the natives, to thofe. lands, and fupport his claim by the loyalty of his fubjeéts upon the fpot. . Our trade to Canada, fo far from being:a benefit to the nation, appears evidently a lofs to individuals, and muft continue fo, as long as the Hudfon’s Bay company are premitted to monopolife at one time,, and-underfell -at another, ( 25 ) another (for finifter reafons) the fair and ‘open trader, who, without combination, can- not long carry ona lofing traffic. The commerce to the ifland of Senegal ‘is of little or no confequence, as gum, which is its principal commodity, can be an article of ‘no great import, without it be to the linnen manufactures. The privilege granted for cutting and carrying away logwood at Honduras will only prove an encouragement to a parcel of infamous freebooters fettled there, who living a moft abandoned and profligate life, are a fcandal to the people from whom they are an outcalt. ' And ‘as to the advantages the Eaft india company will reap from the peace, and the prefent flourifhing fiate of their affairs in Afia, as that is a moft deftruétive monopoly, drain- ing us of our filver, both fpecie and bullion, for unwholefome herbs and crockery ware, ‘fo the more thriving and extenfive their trade is, the more pernicious it muft prove to the nation, After this, my Lord, I think your moft zealous advocates for the advantages we gain by the preliminaries, muft be forced to avow them merely chimerical, whil& the difhonour we fuftain by making the important reftitu- tionsis and ever willbe indelible. Perhaps, my Lord, {6meofyour partifans mayafk, how came itthat fo many of the refignees {till condefcend- Ei ed ( 26 ) ed to remain in poft after the preliminaries were figned, andevenratified? They could not be ignorant of their contents, or the fuppofed difhonour that is thereby caft upon the na- tion: why then did they not throw up their places upon their firft appearance ? Can Mr. T—, who was fo ftrenuous in recommending and defending the preliminaries the day they were canvafled in the H—e of C——s, be convinced of the difingenuity of his reafoning, or the fallacy of his own arguments ? Or, are his eyes opened all of a fudden by infpiration, which has enabled him to difcover the fhamefulnefsandignominy oftheterms? Thefe queiiions may be very eafily anfwered. Mr.: T—, nor any other of the refignees, fince the figning of the preliminaries, were then ac- quainted with the tenor and drift of the /e- cret articles-—whofe dangerous confequences and malignant influence—no true patriot, no honeft man would countenance. Iam forry, my Lord, to make ufe of fuch har(h expretfions; but I acknowledge .he good of my country, which I have fo greatly at heart, operating ftrongly upon me, in the heat of argument, an unguarded word may efcape me. Efad we carried on the war with the fame {pirit that we have thefe three laft years, we might in a fhort time have made ourfelves mafters of all Louifiana, without being eooped ( 87’) cooped up with that narrow boundary the Miffifippi, poffefled ourfelves of all Cuba, St. Domingo and Hifpaniola, and all the Weft Indian iflands without exception : then made a defcent upon Terra Firma, and be- come matters of all the Spanifh provinces in South America. Having cut off this refource to the court of Madrid, their forces would foon have languifhed, and we might eafily have turned the tables upon the Spaniards in favour of the Portuguefe, and foon brought the firft under the Jatter’s fubje@tion. Hav- ing accomplifhed this great point, in favour of his moft Faithful Majefty, we might by the fame means, that is, having all the trade and treafures of North and South America in our hands,.have enabled the King of Pruffia to defeat all the wicked defigns of the Em- prefs Queen, and his other enemies againft him and the Proteftant caufe. Thirty mil- lion of money would purchafe all the inha- bitants of Germany (though by the bye we have fpent forty millions this war there, and are now juft where we fet out) which might foon have been brought from the new world ; and having furnifhed his Pruffian Majefty with an army of 800,c00 ¢ffeCtive men, he would foon have been in a-condition to de- throne her Imperial Majefty, and we fhould have had the fatisfaction to fee a Proteftant Emperor of our own election. This great : E 2 ftroke ( 98 ) ftroke being effeéted in favour of the liber. ties of Europe, we fhould then have had nothing to do but to attack the Grand Signior, dethrone him, and place a Proteftant Prince upon the Ottoman throne. We then might have carried our fuccef:ful arms farther Eaft, and in a fhort time have made ourfelves complete mailers of Afia — and then — what then? Why, like Alexander, we fhould have mourned we had not more worlds to conquer. However romantic this may at firft ap- pear, itmuft have been the neceflary and in- evitable confequence of having pufhed the war with vigour, and not fubmitted to the prefent inglorious terms of pacification, I know but two arguments that can with any face be oppoied to this. The firft is, that, before we had entirely accomplifhed this great plan of operations, our national debt might have been fo immenfely increafed, that we could not have been able any way to pay the aggregate intereft, and the nation muft have become abiolutely a bankrupt, The fecond is, that had we fucceeded to the utmoft of our withes, and gained every one of thefe dominions, we could neither have defended, or expected to have remained in quiet poffeflion of them, fince we muft have excited the jealoufy of all Europe, and even our own created Proteftant Emperor. In -—=— @e& S| FH SS FF ATR | wee A, OE FP FS FS FH EP FP HK FP we af ( 29 ) In anfwer to thefe oppofed arguments, I be'teve it is a received maxim in politics, that no people, or fet of people, either na- tives or foreigners, whofe intereft it is to fupport a government, will ever (as long as fuch their intereft remains) either directly or indirectly undermine it. This being a fet- tled axiom, that even Macbiavel could not contradict, it muft neceffarily follow, that the greater number we intereft in the fate of the nation, fo many more we eftablith friends to the ftate. Now, as we have al- ready gained the cordiality, zx this refped?, of about one million three hundred and fixty thoufand individuals (at a hundred pounds a head) foreigners and natives, by the national debt ; if we could increafe it to three times the fum of 136,000,000]. which it now a- mounts. to, we fhould make fure of the greateft, that is, the richeft part of Europe, as our attached and certain friends ; which might eafily be done by purfuing the war for only twenty years,—a belligerant period of no great extent, confidering the forty years war we often read of in the annals of Branden- burg. With refpcé to the intereft of the national debt, if that fhould amount to more than we could conveniently pay in fpecie, which it might eafily do upon thefe princi- | ples, ( 30 ) ples, confidering we are only reckoned to have about twelve millions’ in all. Great Britain; it would be neceflary to create a fufficient number of additional Bank drills, and other paper currency, which fully an- fwer the intent of fpecie, are more portable to individuals, and lefs burthenfome to the ftate. And, if it fhould ever be. though ex- pedient to pay off the national debt, not with a fpunge, we have always projectors in fuch numbers to affift us, that the thing might be done by calculation in a fortnight. Henriques will throw as many figures upon paper, as will fill a theet in an inftant, and in another divide them into fo many parts, that there will fcarce be left a fhilling in the pound— and Ma//y’s fliding rule will multiply them into farthings, before we know whether they are pounds, fhillings or pence.—Such ge- niufes are ufeful toa ftate; 1 wonder they do not meet with greater encouragement. As to the fecond objection, when.once we had made ourfelves mafters of all America, Afia, and I might throw in Africa, with the connexions and pofleffions we fhould then have in Europe; we certainly fhould bea match for all the Princes of Europe leagued together, and, in defpite of all jealoufy and envy at our fuccefs, they would find it their true intereft to keep in with us, leit we fhould ferve them juft as we had ferved the other ( 3r ) othet three parts of the world: fo that France, Spain, Ruffia, and even the Pro- teftant Emperor himéelf, notwithftanding his craving and eriterprizing fpirit, would be glad to court our friendfhip, if not pay us tribute. The difficulty of peopling and de- fending thefe vaft poffeffions, I acknowledge is not fo eafily got over—but as we might embody the militia of Africa, and march the trained-bands of Afia, if neceflity fhould re- quire, by incorporating afew of our regulars with, and eftablifhing a proper difcipline. in thofe quarters, this obftacle would not be in- furmountable ; efpecially as our continental friends, ever ready at emigration, would flock thither in fhoals upon the leaft encourage- ment. The Germans would certainly be glad of any other country, fince they will not defend their, own, without being paid for it by foreigners, who have no intereft in their protection. Our miffing of thefe , great and extenfive conquefts may, my Lord, be looked upon amongft the moft ftriking difadvantages of patching up this rafh and precipitate peace. It is true, they cannot be confidered as more than negative difadvantages, whilft the be- nign influence and. bleflings of tranquillity are fure and permanent—nourifhing our manufactures, cherifhing our trade, and cir- culating our riches to every corner of the ifland > ( 32 ) ifland; butthen, how far greater would have been this circulation; how much more ex- tenfive would have been our exports ! and how ftill more flourifhing would have been our commerce to every quarter of the globe. It were needle(s to labour at any argument to evince this; common fenfe muft at the firft glance prove it to every man’s under- ftanding ; and if the members of the oppo- fition fhould be hard driven to affign a reafon for their refignations and attack upon your Lordfhip’s adm—~—n, they may always have recourfe to this invincible and folid ar- gument, the negative lof of all Afia, Africa, South America, and the remainder of the Weft Indian iflands. I believe, my Lord, you will labour un- der no {mall difficulty, when called upon, as doubtle/s you will be, by public inquiry into your adm——n, to vindicate this part of your conduct ; not to mention fuch other points of malverfation as I have already cited. In this dilemma, I think the moft friendly ad- vice that can be given you, would be to re- tire from power and employment, into the moft fequeftered part of Scotland, and there, by a reclufe and penitent life, make all the atonement in your power for the manifold fins and crimes you have been guilty of to- wards G—d, your S—-n, and the Nation. This ( 25 ) This might carry the air of envy, anda defire to fupplant you in fome important poft, had I not already fo clearly fet forth the caufes of our difguit, and the full refo- lution of every man of us not to /ubmit to let ourfelves be appointed to any place, how- ever important, however lucrative. The prefent oppofition avows the fame principles, and acts upon the fame generous and national | plan of all the great oppofitions fince the re- volution,who having nothing but the real good of their country at heart,could never be biaffed by perfonal intereft, deluded by profits; or feduced by titles ; it would therefore be fruit- lefs to attempt filencing us by a ribbon or a place—we foar above fuch mean influence. It is publickly reported, that your Lord- fhip intends to ufe your intereft to take off the late additional tax upon porter, fo burthen- fome to the poorer fort of people, particu- larly labourers, to whom it is both food and nourifhment, in order to lay it upon fome article that is not fo immediately connected with the neceflaries of the working part of the nation. Indeed it is faid that your Lord- thip flrenuoufly oppofed this tax at the time of its Seing laid on, “reprefenting the hard- fhip it would be to the mechanical world, and was inclined tu produce the fum required by anadditional impoft upon rum and melaties, articles of luxury and fuperfluity ; but that F for ( 26 ) for fome private confideration, this was fe jected. Doubtlefs, this popular meafure, your Lordfhip has been excited to, in order, if poffible, to wean the sie from that pre- judice and difguft they have to you and your adm n: but can it be believed that the people of England will ever approve the con- duét of a Scotchman, when even his fellow countrymen, and thofe of fome tank in the ftate, unite againft him, not through any per- fonal pique, private refentment, difappointed ambition, or in the expectation of oppofing themfelves into power or office ; but merely and fincerely for the good of their country, which they have fo tenacioufly at heart, and to fruftrate fuch dangerous and deftructive meéafures as your Lordfhip has lately purfued, and I have taken upon myfelf thus to expofe in vindicating the conduct of the members of the prefent glorious Oppofition. If this fhould any way look like an ac- knowledgment, that it were poffible for a Scotchman to be honeft and patriotic, and {uch a conceffion were to be made in favour of the four Scotch Members of the oppo: fition; it would be neceffary to obferve at the fame time, they are the only exception to the general opinion fo univerfally and juftly entertained of that nation. it were almoft unneceffary at this time to remind your Lordthip, of what has been fo often a re ee ee a ee ee ee a ee 27 often and loudly complained of by every Englifhman and Hibernian, who has been difappointed of promotion’ during this war : I mean the ftriking partiality in favour of the Scotch. This object alone, once would have imagined, fhould have prompted you to have putfued the war at all events, till fuch time as you had amply and compleatly provided for all your friends, on the other fide of the Tweed. I fay, my Lord, from this confi- deration, one would have imagined, a French and Spanifh war would have been the moft eligible meafure for the fecurity and fupport of your adm n, though additional fup- plies had been ever fo difficult to raife, and though honourable terms of accommodation had been offered on the part of the bellige- rant powers. It is true even then, you never would have been able to gain over the four Scotch members of the oppofition, but per- haps fome indirect method might have been found to have foftened their refentment, by providing for fome of their friends and rela~ tions in the army and navy. This may in- deed,my Lord, be looked upon as a great over- fight in your politics,at a time you fhould have taken every poffible ftep to infure your totter- ing power, efpecially amonftyour fellow coun- trymen, whole oppofition muft convey a very unfavourable idea of your conduct and de- figns. Such miftaken policy was a fure pre- F 3 fage ( 28 ) fige of the blunders and inattention to our proper intereft which we were to expect at the hands of fuch a ftatefman in the framing of a peace. As this grievous complaint is now ina great meafure at an end, by reafon of the pacific meafures that are taking place: fo we are rather led to confider the confequences of your not more amply purfuing it, than to manifeft our refentment at your former partiality ; a partiality fo great, that we have always {een Scotch troops employed upon the moft arduous and dangerous enterprizes, whereby you furnifhed them with an oppor- tunity of fignalizing their courage and vigilance in fo {triking a manner, as to give colour to many promotions, which looked like a recom- pence for their paft fervices, By thefe glorious occafions, you enabled them to rifque their lives in purfuit of honour and preferment, which many Englifh and Irifh officers, for want of thefe favourable opportunities, could not gain. As this channel of national partiality is now ftopped, we muft expect to {ce it ftream in other courfes: all Canada, will perhaps, be fettled by Scotchmen, efpecially if the Englifh fhould not chufe to flock there in numbers fufficient to people and cultivate fo cold and extenfive a country: we may ex- pect to fee half a dozen more new bridges erected 29 erected over the Tweed—All foreign fnufts prohibited, and nothing but Scotch allowed to be taken, even at court; nor need we be furprifed if her ——— fhould appear the next birth-day, in plaid colour filk, to make ita reigning fafhion ; or that a jaunt to Edin- burgh fhould be ascommon as one to Kew. One of the writers on our fide of the quef- tion, has indeed, fuggefted, that if things went on fo fwimingly for a few years in fa- vour of Scotland, we might expect to fee a Royal Palace built there for the fixed refi- dence of the court; but this I cannot per- fuade myfelf, will take place any time thefe ten years, confidering the preparations that mutt be previoufly made. The writer of the North Briton, our fa- vourite author, has fo amply and decently evinced the political tenets of the prefent Tories (in one of his late difquifitions *) that it is matter of wonder and aftonifhment to me, how they will ever be able to anfwer him, or henceforward hold up their heads, He has ciearly proved, that they would certainly have joined the rebels, both in 1715 and 1745, if their courage had been equal to their affection for the Pretender. Another reafon might, I think, with due fubmiffion to that learned writer, be afligned, is, that their regimentals were not ready in time, by reafon of the number of journey- * Saturday, January 8. a et ITS a Coge y journeymen taylors then employed in bearing arms» They would, neverthelefs, certainly have marched to join the rebels in 174.5, if their arms and ammunition had not been fo opportunely feized in Lincoln’s-Inn-Fields Playhoufe. It is, however, a happy confi- deration, that they have not courage fuffici- ent to fupport their evil defigns in the field ; as, however deep their political machinati- ons may be, however notorious their princi- ples and attachments, and however numerous their body, their pol/treonery will always keep them in due fubjection. There is one circumftance, which the North Briton. has in this Portrait of the mo- dern Tories, fo nicely touched upon, that.no- thing but the pencil of fo great a matter, cou!d fo judicioufly have hit off; I mean the entire reformation of the political principles of the Tories, during Mr. P—’s adm n, He does not, indeed, affign any reafon for this extraora'nary temporary change, which clearly evinces the Tories are attached to men and not mea/ures. I may, indeed, be afked, fince this writer has fo amply proved all the Tories rank Ja- cobites, and every one of them defirous of bringing in the Pretender ; how came it that knowing by experience, and convinced of their principles, we ever united with them in the fame adm—n, in the purfuit of the fame ‘ objects a 7” ( 31 ) objects, in fupport of the fame Prince? In an{wer to this, let it-be remembered, that it is not individuals but expedients we oppofe. In one word, wechimed in with the Zor7es till the lofs of Newfoundland (which fo greatly flurred the reputation of the Scotch M—r) till their avowed arbitrary tenets, which I have already mentioned, became manifeft, and the pre- fent inglorious peace took place. I have not in this place infifted upon the negative difadvantages we fuftain by a fuf- penfion of armsin the four quarters of the world, or the imputation of ingratitude we fhall lay under by all Europe, for having brought the King of Pruffia into this war, and left him in the lurch—without attending 4 thofe glorious motives—the fupport of proteftantifm in the empire, and the ballance of power, in purfuit of which we have fo zealoufly raifed our national debt to 136 millions, By this one ftep we have given up all future pretence to determine the quarrels of the princes of Germany, a privilege we have never yielded to any other power «ince the revolution.—This claim, which we have fupported for almoft a cen- tury #t .12 price of fo much blood, and trea- fure ; v7a'ch we have hitherto confidered as much out birth-right as the fovereignty of the fea, we have thus inglorioufly yiclded, thus pufilanimonfly given up. If after this, my Lord, you fhould not be con- (: 32. ) convinced of the upright motives, which) have influenced the prefent’ Whig oppofition: —of the impracticability of. ever regaining their affeCtion, or re-uniting with them--if you {hould not be convinced of the impropriety, difadvantage, and. danger, (to fay no’ worfe) : of thel eading rule’ of your admin—n,’ in granting your S n the full liberty of name’ ing his own fervants, and keeping them ‘in power as long as they pleafe—if this:uncon- {titutional prerogative (never before allowed any prince of the houfe of H r upon the’ Uritifh throne), fhould not appear to'you in its moft glaring and. baneful light—if you fhould not be co. : *.2d of the difhonour of | the terms of the prei. .t peace, with the /ecret : articles fapprefled to public eyes :. in a word, » if. your’ Lordfhip, fhould not, immediately, upon your reading this, infift upon refigning » your employments, that more able; faithfal.: and popular M rs.may take the reins of: government into their hands; you ‘muit be | callous to all conviction, blind to your own: > perfonal fecurity, and refolved to’complete the: : facrifice of the nation, » So that,:if it were: ; not impoflible, it would be fruitlefs in::me.’ to. urge thefe points any ftronger; or diiplay ' the contraft of your and former adm——ns: | But; being convinced of the force of’ my rea:. 1 foning, and the likelihood theres is of your taking my advice, I fubfcribe myfelf . if | Your's: &e.!s 11 1